Medical journal retracts nine more articles authored by former editor-in-chief

Medical journal retracts nine more articles authored by former editor-in-chief


Credit score: Pixabay/CC0 Public Area

The British Journal of Sports activities Drugs has retracted 9 additional non-research articles, authored by former editor in chief Dr. Paul McCrory, and an “expression of concern” might be positioned on 38 others revealed in BMJ journals on which he’s the one writer.

These newest retractions observe the retraction earlier this yr of an editorial within the British Journal of Sports activities Drugs, prompted by considerations that the article shared similarities with one written for Physics World.

McCrory, at present of the Florey Institute of Neuroscience and Psychological Well being, Melbourne, Australia, edited the journal between 2001 and 2008, throughout which period he revealed not less than 164 articles in BMJ journals—most of them within the British Journal of Sports activities Drugs.

The choice to retract these articles follows an inside investigation by BMJ’s analysis integrity workforce and the present editor in chief of the British Journal of Sports activities Drugs. This was prompted by allegations made by researcher Dr. Nick Brown about publication misconduct.

The 9 retractions all concern opinion items, commentaries, and editorials on which McCrory is the one writer: They comprise 5 instances of plagiarism and three of redundant publication.

Within the different retracted article, McCrory inaccurately quotes and misrepresents the place of Dr. Augustus Thorndike, as said in an earlier 1952 publication.

The quote distorts Thorndike’s suggestions for managing ongoing participation involved sports activities after concussion, which McCrory used to assist his stance within the article.

Given the sample of publication misconduct on McCrory’s half, revealed by each BMJ’s investigations, the writer has determined that an expression of concern needs to be positioned on all content material revealed in its journals, together with within the British Journal of Sports activities Drugs, the place he’s recognized as the one writer to alert readers to the conclusions of those investigations.

An editorial setting out the small print of the most recent investigation and revealed on-line within the British Journal of Sports activities Drugs highlights McCrory’s “most influential work”: 5 iterations of the worldwide consensus tips on concussion which have been developed in 2001, 2004, 2008, 2012, and 2016, and revealed within the journal.

After a evaluation of the 2016 concussion consensus assertion, the analysis integrity workforce concluded that it had “no considerations about plagiarism,” and thought of that “the query of the extent of McCrory’s contribution to, and affect on, the 5 variations of the consensus assertion is a matter throughout the purview of the scientific committee appointed by the Concussion in Sport Group (CISG).”

The editorial notes that after the plagiarism allegations first surfaced, McCrory resigned his management place within the CISG, a world affiliation of clinicians and scientists with an curiosity in sports-related concussion, and stepped down from his function as a member of the Scientific Committee of the Worldwide Consensus Convention on Concussion in Sport.

BMJ has recognized 40 analysis articles revealed in its journals on which McCrory was a co-author:18 of those have been revealed throughout his tenure as editor in chief of The British Journal of Sports activities Drugs.

“We’ve got not acquired any particular allegation of misconduct relating to those papers,” states the editorial, which concludes with a promise to analyze any additional allegations about McCrory’s publication file in BMJ journals.

“The scientific file depends on belief, and BMJ’s belief in McCrory’s work –particularly the articles that he has revealed as a single writer—is damaged. We’ll examine any new allegations that we obtain about McCrory’s work in BMJ journals. We ask different publishers and his establishment to do the identical.”

Sports activities drugs society updates concussion tips

Extra info:
Replace on the investigation of the publication file of former BJSM editor-in-chief Paul McCrory, British Journal of Sports activities Drugs (2022). DOI: 10.1136/bjsports-2022-106408

Supplied by
British Medical Journal

Medical journal retracts 9 extra articles authored by former editor-in-chief (2022, October 10)
retrieved 10 October 2022

This doc is topic to copyright. Other than any truthful dealing for the aim of personal research or analysis, no
half could also be reproduced with out the written permission. The content material is supplied for info functions solely.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are makes.